
Part 1 of 3: Regulatory environment
Introduction
Reading economic forecasts that UK will enter recession sooner, rather than later, I wondered whether the UK Challenger Banks have robust proposition (services’ portfolio) and are sufficiently capitalised, i.e. keep their gearing in check, to weather the cooled down economic climate.
Coming into the matter with an open mind, I’ve done a high-level scan of a number of UK-operating challenger banks and financial services providers’ public profiles (products/services) across a number of criteria, such as:
- Part 1: Statutory compliance: e.g. checks and tests by Bank of England (BoE) and/or Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), any special requirements for financial services providers in this sector;
- Part 2: Their financial strength: various data on actual and projected capitalisation, degree of gearing, etc.;
- Brand value: to what extent a brand value is likely to provide an advantage in a cooling down economy?
- Part 3: Number of customers: strength in numbers?
- Number and variety of products / services: does diversification offer a safety cushion or specialisation in a particular product line offer enough depth to weather a recession?
You may ask, why bother, they go down and then recover, so what?
The answer is: picking undervalued stock in the bear market, if it is available to private investors, of course, in expectation of its rising value in the next spiral-turn of economic growth. The trick is not to invest into a company that will dive and never duck back out!
Or, to prepare for recession, which bank is a safer option for us as private and corporate customers.
Statutory compliance
Leaving aside the question about BoE stress-testing, none of the challengers are yet big enough to have systemic impact on the UK financial industry’s stability.
Capital requirements
Well, you would be relieved to know that since 2017 Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) has been easing its “approach to Pillar 2A capital, a rule regarding the add-ons of capital which individual banks must set aside above sector-wide minimums” with specific application to mortgage services. A more individual approach, as opposed to the regulator’s standardised model, now takes into account the depth of the risk data and operational experience to calibrate the capital add-ons. Privilege of using bespoke models was previously a competitive advantage of larger incumbent banks. Now your challenger mortgage provider competes in a more levelled competitive field.
Minimum requirement for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL)
However, FCA ‘giveth’ and BoE ‘taketh’: whilst being generous with more than a dozen new banking licences by Q3 2019, BoE has a fairly new requirement for “minimum requirement for own funds and eligible liabilities” (MREL) to maintain sufficient equity and debt resources that can absorb losses and provide for recapitalisation in resolution by the banks with assets over £15 billion. This threshold is significantly lower compared to the US ($250 billion) and the Eurozone (€100 billion). In the UK, MREL rules are more stringent than the US and the Eurozone meaning the qualifying UK challenger banks are obligated to keep large amounts of expensive equity and debt.
Product offerings limited by regulation
It also appears that “ringfencing” rules (the rules apply to any UK bank with more than £25 billion in customer deposits) have damaged the challenger banks’ competitive edge in the market for certain types of corporate services, as such services can only be provided by a ‘non-ringfenced’ UK bank.
And, finally, Brexit (transition period of 11 months starting now) in combination with Payments Services Directive (PSD) by European Central Bank (ECB) somewhat complicates a cross-border product / service proposition with mandatory passporting regime for the UK-licenced financial services providers. Eurozone financial products’ passporting is yet another competitive hurdle to overcome for a number of challengers, but to a lesser degree for the EU-headquartered or the ones with subsidiaries in the Eurozone countries: N26 (Austria, France, Germany, Italy and Spain), Monese (Germany), Bunq (€ Travel Card), Revolut (over 150 currencies’ multi-spend and money transfer card), etc.
Accounting standards and disclosure
It is assumed that all UK deposit taking challenger banks prepare their financial accounts using IFRS 9 Financial Instruments – the current UK accounting standard for banks. There shouldn’t be any advantage or disadvantage in the playing field as all financial reports will adhere to the same accounting standard.
Before Brexit, the UK Financial Institutions have been subjected to the European Union Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) and Capital Requirements Regulations (CRR) implemented on 1 January 2014. The CRR and CRD, commonly known as CRD IV, which provide consistent capital adequacy standards for financial services companies and an associated supervisory framework across the European Union are enforced in the UK by the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA). It may appear that upon the completion of the eleven months’ Brexit transition period on 31 December 2020, PRA might have made the above regulations more stringent and robust. Watch this space.
Other best practice standards and disclosure requirements include, but are not limited to:
- Assessing and disclosing of Credit Risk Exposure, including Counterparty, using for example Basic, Standardised or Advanced Approaches. Based on the availability of their own data, Standardised Approach is typical for challenger banks. Note: Credit risk is the risk of financial loss to the bank if a customer, or counterparty to a financial instrument, fails to meet its contractual obligations, and arises principally from the Bank’s receivables from customers. The risk of financial loss from the Bank’s exposures to other financial institutions and investment securities is reported as counterparty credit risk;
- Assessment, Rating and Reporting of Liquid Assets;
- Assessing and disclosing of Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (IRRBB);
- Calculating and reporting on Risk Weighted Exposure Amounts and Operational Risk Capital;
- Adoption of a specific and well-defined risk framework, such as Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERMF), approved by PRA and FCA, including:
- Measuring and reporting on Operational Risk. Note: The Risk that failures arising from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems or from external events that may cause monetary loss, service disruption or customer detriment;
- Measuring and reporting on Market Risk. Note: The risk that changes in market rates negatively impact the earnings or market value of the Bank’s assets or liabilities, income or costs;
- Brexit Risk, i.e. exposure to detrimental effects of Brexit on the economy and the FIs is notably present in some of the UK challenger banks’ Annual and Pillar 3 Reports. Interesting to see how the challenger sector deals with this risk during the eleven months transition period.
What is the importance of imposing all of the above on non-systemically important challenger banks? The answer can be demonstrated within the following example:
In January 2019 Metro Bank admitted to making an accounting error by underestimating the risks taken on commercial real estate loans by £900 million ($1.2 billion). Another finding by BoE’s audit was that Metro Bank’s real estate loan risk was 50% greater than previously reported. Specifically, Metro Bank gave some real estate loans a 35% risk weighting when the weighting should have been 100%, underestimating the risks taken on some loans by 65%. The incident and potential effect of the above error was compared by international market analysts and investors to some practices that triggered the events of Financial Crisis of 2008.
It is out of the question that Metro Bank would have collapsed the market in 2019 due to its non-systemic importance within the UK financial system. But the example serves as a warning that in pursuit of market share and faster growth, accounting standards, risk practices / calculations and disclosure should be under constant scrutiny. I assume that the BoE may have audited the books of other UK challenger banks. If not, assuming they all may theoretically have had ‘accounting errors’ and inadequate credit risk exposure calculators, their combined UK books might have caused substantial distress in the event of severe and/or prolonged recession.
Part 1: In conclusion
In summary, some concessions in certain product types (mortgages) help with offering cheaper competitive products by the challenger banks. On the other hand, they have to comply with very expensive capital adequacy requirements, i.e. keep low-performing reserves. In addition, the challenger banks, because they lack non ring-fenced status, cannot enter the market for some lucrative, highly-risky, but also highly profitable service propositions to large corporates.
Whether transition from London Inter-Bank Offered Rate (LIBOR) in the loan market to risk-free interest rate benchmarks (FCA publications) by end-2021 will impair the challenger bank’s competitiveness, needs to be seen. However, I assume it will boost it.
None of the existing Challenger Banks have been identified as having any global or domestic UK systemic importance; assuming that statutory compliance requirements, accounting standards and mandatory disclosure rules are adhered to, any threat from the segment of the challenger banks can be considered minimal even in the event of severe recession.
There is a possible scenario that in the event of any of the UK challenger banks becoming financially or statutory compliance vulnerable, they may become a target of a friendly or hostile acquisition attempt by the current incumbents. Example: persistent rumours of a potential bid from Lloyds Banking Group for somewhat ‘vulnerable’ Metro Bank. Watch this space.
Disclosure: Financial Botanik is not supported by referral fees from any party. The article does not cover each and every participant in the market or all of their product / services. The information which is contained in these articles is subject to change at any time. Financial Botanik aims to help readers gain better understanding of the market and its driving events, promote discussion and increase financial awareness.
