
After I wrote my previous paper on Comparison and analysis of selected ‘Umbrella Company’ services in the IR35 regime for Freelancers, among other pertinent questions and discussion points one has really taken the centre-stage: the issue with deducting of Employer’s NIC and Levy from the worker’s gross pay.
Employer’s NI at e.g. 13.8% and Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5% are classified as a so called ‘employer’s cost’ incurred either by your Agency or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider, the so-called by HMRC ‘the fee-payer or deemed employer’. I found explanations ambiguous by the ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Providers and HMRC’s guidance as extremely casuistic (maybe HMRC new ‘Guide’ provides a better explanation and confirms the obligations of various parties in plain business language).
Killer question
Why under the UK employment tax law a ‘worker’, an entity without an incorporated status, would be responsible for the Employer’s statutory payments to HMRC?
Available guidance
To find an answers or definitive guidance, I’ve read the following HMRC pages (https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/employment-status-manual/esm2390 ) and found the following statements:
An Agency or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider, the so-called by HMRC ‘the fee-payer or deemed employer’, can recover either Employer’s NI at e.g. 13.8% or Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5% from the worker’s gross pay.
The ‘how’ is well explained, an Agency or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider just deduct 14.3% from the contract amount received from the Client. The ‘why’ is still murky. When I worked for various employers on permanent basis, I do not remember that my contractual core / base remuneration was reduced by the percentage or amount of Employer’s NICs or levies. In fact, until I became an employer myself, I never bothered what these rates were.
On HMRC pages I find further references to the ‘how’ question such as “On receipt of payment from the recruitment agency, the umbrella company has its overheads to cover so will typically retain:
- its administration fee;
- an amount to meet their employer’s National Insurance contributions (NICs) obligation;
- holiday payment;
- allowable expenses;
- other amounts to cover other specific costs, such as apprenticeship levy.
- The remainder of the payment is paid to the worker as gross pay which is then subject to PAYE to deduct Income Tax and employee’s NICs.”
There is another statement by HMRC in the section ‘Payslip’: “The inclusion of employer’s NICs on the payslip often causes confusion with workers who believe they are paying the employer’s deductions. This is not the case as employer’s NICs is deducted from the payment the umbrella company receives from the recruitment agency which they have the legal right to.
Employers, which includes umbrella companies, cannot by law deduct employer’s NICS from a worker’s gross pay.”
Conclusion
Unless there is further guidance, which I cannot locate (?), the above HMRC statements contradict each other and point to an area of gross injustice towards the Contract Worker – cutting the hard-earned contractual pay amount by 14.3% to foot the Employer’s obligation to HMRC.
Summary
- I find the quoted statements / guidance by HMRC casuistic: unless an uplift amount of 13.8% and 0.5% is charged by the Agency to the Client on top of the agreed daily rate, the deduction is from the ‘worker’s’ pay, disregarding all demagogy about its ‘gross’ and ‘net’ status;
- On that basis I recommend that you, when negotiating with any type of ‘the fee-payer or deemed employer’ specifically challenge the above charges and ask for confirmation that these particular taxes will not be deductible from your daily pay. If, any Employer’s level taxes and fees are due they should be re-charged to the actual ‘Client’, i.e. become an addition to the daily rate. That means you probably should negotiate with the end-Client a rate that includes the above uplifts totalling circa 14.5%;
- Finally, if the Client, Agency and/or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider are in denial, I recommend that you seek advice “from the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) via their helpline number 0300 123 1100 or the ACAS Helpline Online tool”.
Good luck, everyone. Happy ‘hunting’: mind your business and negotiate. If in need of advice – ask and discuss!
Disclaimer: please note that due to on-going reviews of IR35 by the Government and HMRC all information provided under the links and on Service Providers websites is subject to change. Always check the latest updates and seek professional advice before you take any contractual, financial and business action or enter into a transaction.

Great analysis. Let’s hope the government sees sense and delays this for at least another year whilst a comprehensive review is undertaken.