Comparison and analysis of selected ‘Umbrella Company’ services in the IR35 regime for Freelancers

“Everything is false, everything is possible, everything is doubtful.”

Guy de Maupassant

“There is no statutory definition of an ‘umbrella company’, although it is generally accepted that an umbrella company is a company that employs temporary workers who work at different end clients’ premises. Umbrella companies do not source work. Typically, the umbrella will enter into a contract with a recruitment agency who will source work from end clients.”

Employment Status Manual, HM Revenue & Customs, published: 7 March 2016 and updated: 23 January 2020

Introduction

‘Umbrella Company’ proposition to service the freelance professionals is one of the most recognisable in the UK market alongside service propositions such as ‘Limited Company’ and ‘Construction Industry Scheme (CIS)’. In the not-so-distant-past the term ‘umbrella’ was also associated with the so-called ‘take-home pay optimisation schemes’. HMRC, however, have suppressed such schemes and investigations are in progress, where freelance contractors owe HMRC various amounts in back taxes. That was the dark hour of the ‘Umbrella Company’ proposition as a lot of hard-working contractors driven by the notions of higher gain (or greed) and trust in the legitimacy of such schemes ended up in debt. According to hearsay, none of the companies, which offered such schemes with the previous HMRC blessing were indebted, unless they failed to run reporting or went financially under due to various financial exposures. The rest have reported every transaction by their members to HMRC and continued business operations. 

So, in consideration of past experience, Lesson Number 1:

  1. Under the ‘Umbrella Company’ service your every operation and transaction will be known and transparent to HMRC, which is good because the Umbrella Service Provider has statutory obligation for the quality and completeness of all financial affairs of the client, at least until the end of a specific contract;
  2. No aspect of the ‘Umbrella Company’ service is exempt from the investigation and the so-called redress by HMRC, i.e. an ultimate right to change rules and collect tax in retrospect;
  3. Quality of service and trust are important, but with the introduction of a more regimental approach specifically to the ‘Umbrella Company’ service the number of differentiators between the providers has drastically reduced.

The search for such differentiators has inspired a quick research and analysis exercise that I present to your attention. Currently there are forty-seven ‘Umbrella Company’ service providers feature as compliant with umbrella services accredited by the Freelancer & Contractor Services Association (FCSA). Needless to say that this number may fluctuate, therefore always check at https://www.fcsa.org.uk/members/. To identify trends, differentiation features or value-add services I went through websites and called thirteen providers. My choice was far from scientific; some companies I knew from my own experience, some had been mentioned by my colleagues, some I’ve picked in discussions with various Agencies and some, to my deep embarrassment, I picked for an interesting name. So, do not treat my list as advertising, promotion or recommendation. Jumping ahead, my overall conclusions are that any other ‘Umbrella Company’ service provider that did not get on my sample list could be as good or even better than the ones on the list. My intention, therefore, is to concentrate on the important features of the service that may help in taking a decision to sign up for the umbrella services. But, enough with the interlude, let’s have a closer look at the contemporary core (statutory) and flexible aspects of the Umbrella Company services.

1. ‘Umbrella Company’ services in the IR35 regime

Essential for the FCSA membership and accreditation is a condition for adherence to the provisions of the coming IR35 legislation. In a nutshell, all service providers are compliant with the active and forthcoming legislation, at least according to the existing compliance checks. I do not have enough data and information to comment on the effectiveness of compliance checks for IR35. There is no doubt that any of the accredited service providers can perform the core IR35 operations (see next section for detail).

Some ‘Umbrella Company’ service providers go an extra mile and provide some or in some cases comprehensive consultations on their websites and this may differentiate them from the competitors. In a wrap up for this section I would like to propose the following scenarios:

  1. Existing service providers that have a substantial portion of the services for ‘Limited Company’ will experience cannibalisation of their business by the ‘Umbrella Company’ services. Whether the Company Net Margin income can compensate for the loss of fees for all services associated with running a Limited Company for a freelancer, I have no definitive empirical, secondary or primary evidence to pass a categoric yes / no.
  2. With my experience in the field I have a hunch that the following derivative scenarios may proliferate in 2020:
    1. Some Service Providers (Umbrella and/or Limited services) may be retaining the business (freelancers picking the same service provider when moving to an ‘umbrella’ engagement model);
    2. Some Service Providers will be losing the business altogether due to more intense competition and lower margins in the ‘Umbrella Company’ side of the business
    3. Majority Service Providers will experience lower margins, declining revenue and more hassle with administration of the ‘umbrella’ services and lower rates of customer retention.
    4. If IR35 is rolled out in its current shape and form with regard to support from HMRC and maturity of operational processes for handling of disputes, management of conflicts, resolution of tax calculations, all four participating players (freelancers, service providers, agencies and HMRC) will experience an elongated period of conflicts and administrative turmoil, which will hit multiple sectors of the UK economy and taxpayers;
    5. If a ‘blanket’ in-scope for IR35 treatment of contracts by a large number of the UK organisations that traditionally employ freelancers, is not actively discouraged by HMRC and the UK’s Minister of State for Employment the matter may lead to a constitutional crisis of denying the UK citizens the right for work. The first result of such crises would be lower tax revenues currently generated by the freelance group of taxpayers, i.e. a diametrically different outcome to that pursued by HMRC with the introduction of IR35.

To summarise, Lesson Number 2: If the IR35 regime is implemented from April 2020 in its current form, the freelance community needs to do what they do the best: embrace the change, do the research and choose a service most suitable for the roles, level of remuneration and model of operation. The following sections discuss variable differentiators and value-add services that can make a difference under the ‘Umbrella Company’ service in the IR35 regime.

2. Core services of ‘Umbrella Company’ in the IR35 regime operations

The accredited service providers can perform the core ‘Umbrella Company’ in the IR35 regime operations such as (please refer to Table 1 for details):

  • Deduct Employer’s NI at e.g. 13.8%
  • Deduct Employee’s NI (by Tax Code)
  • Deduct Income Tax (by Tax Code)
  • Deduct the Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5%
  • Charge a varying Company Net Margin of either weekly (most typical) or monthly frequency
  • Calculate and accrue the Holiday Pay
  • Calculate and deduct statutory Pension Employer and Employee’s Contributions (these kick in after 3 months / 12 weeks period after the start of the engagement)
  • Guarantee statutory employment rights such as Statutory Sick Pay (SSP), Maternity and Paternity Pay at the nominal minimal rates established by HMRC (more information at HMRC SSP page and HMRC SMP pages).
  • Provide Professional Indemnity, Employer’s Liability and Public Liability insurance cover, which is included in the Company Net Margin charge.

The above core operations require an explanatory narrative that I’ve grouped under the following list:

  • All surveyed Service Providers in Table 1 have stated that an Umbrella Company as an employer can only make payments into a personal UK-based bank account where you are a named account holder. In other word, any attempt to run a hybrid ‘Umbrella-Limited company’ model is out of question;
  • Employer’s NI at e.g. 13.8% and Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5% are classified as a so called ‘employer’s cost’ incurred either by your Agency or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider, the so-called by HMRC ‘the fee-payer or deemed employer’. Yes, there are two models of employment in the market – ask if there are options! I found this area very grey in explanations by the ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Providers and casuistic in the guidance provided by HMRC (see Lesson Number 3); 
  • There is an option to either have holiday accrued and paid when one takes time off; or paid out each time you are paid on a ‘rolled up pre-paid’ basis, which therefore means when you take holiday you will not receive additional payment;
  • If opted-in, three months after the commencement of the engagement an Umbrella Company will start deductions into one of the following pensions:
  • Workplace pension scheme via NEST – this is a statutory government scheme in the absence of an open market pension services provider from the Umbrella Company
  • The Umbrella Company scheme with their preferred pension company from the open market. It is a bonus when the freelancer and Umbrella Company’s pension companies are the same: contributions will get consolidated in one fund and theoretically grow at a faster rate;
  • If an opt-out from the above options by an Umbrella Company is exercised, a freelancer-employee loses the Employer’s contribution and can only rely on private contributions into a personal pension fund (see next section on support for contributions to a personal pension fund);
  • My understanding from the interviews with the Service Providers dynamics with the pension contributions may be as follows:
    • In the case where only NEST and Umbrella pension schemes are involved, when a freelancer-employee is idle (i.e. no contract payments are in-coming, and, naturally no pension contributions are made), for as long as such freelancer-employee stays with the same Umbrella Company, when the payments resume, the pension contributions resume without an additional three months incubation period;
    • If a freelancer-employee left an Umbrella Company for a period and then returned, enrolment to the NEST scheme will commence after the statutory three months, but the enrolment to Umbrella pension scheme is immediate.
    • I treat this area as grey, as I cannot find any written evidence to support the above. It is recommended to check the Umbrella Company’s contract for all detail on pension contributions management.

In summary, takeaways for Lesson Number 3 are:

  1. I’ve read the following HMRC pages (https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/employment-status-manual/esm2390 ) in attempt to find confirmation or directive that an Agency or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider, the so-called by HMRC ‘the fee-payer or deemed employer’, can recover either Employer’s NI at e.g. 13.8% or Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5% from the worker’s gross pay and found the following information on the subject of ‘Why under the UK employment tax laws a ‘worker’ may be responsible for the Employer’s statutory payments to HMRC?’:
    1. On HMRC pages I find references such as “On receipt of payment from the recruitment agency, the umbrella company has its overheads to cover so will typically retain:
      1. its administration fee;
      2. an amount to meet their employer’s National Insurance contributions (NICs) obligation;
      3. holiday payment;
      4. allowable expenses;
      5. other amounts to cover other specific costs, such as apprenticeship levy. The remainder of the payment is paid to the worker as gross pay which is then subject to PAYE to deduct Income Tax and employee’s NICs.”
    2. There is another statement by HMRC in the section ‘Payslip’: “The inclusion of employer’s NICs on the payslip often causes confusion with workers who believe they are paying the employer’s deductions. This is not the case as employer’s NICs is deducted from the payment the umbrella company receives from the recruitment agency which they have the legal right to. Employers, which includes umbrella companies, cannot by law deduct employer’s NICS from a worker’s gross pay.”;
    3. I find such statements / guidance by HMRC rather casuistic: unless an uplift amount of 13.8% and 0.5% is charged by the Agency to the Client on top of the agreed daily rate, the deduction is from the ‘worker’s’ pay, disregarding all demagogy about its ‘gross’ and ‘net’ status; 
    4. On that basis I recommend that you, when negotiating with any type of ‘the fee-payer or deemed employer’ specifically challenge the above charges and ask for confirmation that these particular taxes will not be deductible from your daily pay. If, any Employer’s level taxes and fees are due they should be re-charged to the actual ‘Client’, i.e. become an addition to the daily rate. That means you probably should negotiate with the end-Client a rate that includes the above uplifts totalling circa 14.5%;
    5. Finally, if the Client, Agency and/or ‘Umbrella Company’ Service Provider are in denial, I recommend that you seek advice ‘from the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) via their helpline number 0300 123 1100 or the ACAS Helpline Online tool”.
  2. The Umbrella Company Net Margin is a decisive differentiator for the so-called net take-home pay amount. Goes without saying, the higher the rate, the more emphasis on a lower rate of the Company Net Margin. Figures in Table 1 are indicative and in most cases presented as a gross rate (some companies reveal the net rate after tax), as the Company Net Margin varies depending on a specific Agency (e.g. Capita). All interviewed umbrella service providers confirmed that they have working agreements with multiple agencies.
  3. Always, call a number of umbrella service providers and request a detailed customised illustration (calculation) of the net take-home pay amount. Ask in writing for the breakdown of all charges, fees, and percentages. Again, figures in Table 1 are indicative and may vary depending on your specific Agency and maybe contract rate. Negotiate!
  4. Choose an Umbrella Company with the best offer for the company pension scheme – it is your forced savings that are also topped up by the State; bank them and make them grow!

Table 1: Comparison of selected Umbrella Company Service Providers (demonstration and reference)

FCSA accredited memberCompany Net
Margin (indicative)
Holiday pay accumulationExpenses allowed in accounting computationsCompany pensionPrivate pension contributions deductionsPhone numberWebsiteEmail
AdvanceGross £20YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)Yes (subject to Supervision, Direction or Control assessment)After 3 months company scheme via Peoples Pension:
Employer – 3%
Employee – 5%
Not supported01244 564 564https://www.advance.online/umbrella-companyhello@advance.online
Black Diamond UmbrellaGross £12YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)Yes (subject to Supervision, Direction or Control assessment)Company scheme via Now Pension:
Employer – ?%
Employee – ?%
Not supported01942 679997https://www.blackdiamondumbrella.co.ukenquiries@blackdiamondaccountancy.com
Brookson LimitedGross £32.50YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)Limited service
MILEAGE – YES
After 3 months workplace pension scheme via NEST:
Employer: 3%
Employee: 2.4%
Company scheme via AEGON
Not supported0800 230 0213
01925 235 701
http://www.brookson.co.uk
https://www.brooksonone.co.uk/services/limited-company/ir35/
contracts@brookson.co.uk
Contractor UmbrellaGross £25 (weekly)
Gross £95 (monthly)
YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)Limited service
MILEAGE – YES
Company scheme via Scottish WidowsNot supported01206 591 000https://www.contractorumbrella.com/resource/what-is-ir35/info@contractorumbrella.com
ForeTwo GroupGross weekly
£25.99 (net £15.41)
YES (paid every week or store it up)Yes (subject to Supervision, Direction or Control assessment)After 6 weeks workplace pension scheme via NESTSupported through payroll0808 196 9601http://www.foretwogroup.co.uk/enquiries@foretwogroup.co.uk
Giant GroupStarting from gross £14 (internet sign-up rate) per week (net £7.36 after tax relief)28 days per year including bank and public holidaysYESWorkplace pension scheme via NEST
Company scheme via Standard Life:
4% of pensionable earnings (the government adds another 1%) and Giant will contribute a further 4% (from funds received from the agency)
Not supported0330 024 0946https://www.giantpay.co.uk/umbrellainfo@giantgroup.com
JSA GroupGross weekly £22 (net £11.90)YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)NOAfter 12 weeks workplace pension scheme via NEST
Company scheme via OPTIONS
Supported0800 25 26 40
01923 257 257
http://jsagroup.co.uk
https://jsagroup.co.uk/services/umbrella-services/
newenquiries@jsagroup.co.uk
NASA GroupGross £17 (net £10) – weeklyYES (both options: accrued and not accrued)Limited service
MILEAGE – YES
Company scheme via NOW Pension:
Employer – 3%
Employee – 5%
YES (gross £5 fee to process)0117 929 7683https://www.nasagroup.co.uk/umbrellasales@nasagroup.co.uk
Orange Genie GroupGross £15-20YES (accrued)YES (to subject to Supervision, Direction or Control assessment)NO (coming March 2020)Supported0129 646 8483http://www.orangegenie.com
https://www.orangegenie.com/umbrella
umbrella@orangegenie.com
info@orangegenie.com
Orbital Payroll GroupGross £18 (for over £300 per week)YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)Limited service
MILEAGE – YES
Company scheme via Smart Pension:
Employer – ?
Employee – ?
Not supported01226 444 445http://www.orbitalservices.co.uk/solutions-and-benefits/#orbital-benefitsinfo@orbitalservices.co.uk
ParasolGross £28.50 (net £16.90)YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)YESWorkplace pension scheme via NEST
Company scheme via Scottish Widows
Not supported0800 464 0519
0800 464 0409
https://www.parasolgroup.co.uk/umbrella/bestadvice@parasolgroup.co.uk
Paystream My Max LimitedSubject to customised illustrationYES (accrued)YES (to subject to Supervision, Direction or Control assessment)Workplace pension scheme via NESTTBC0161 516 5376
Contracts & Compliance (Including IR35): 0808 164 4460
http://www.paystream.co.uk
https://www.paystream.co.uk/umbrella/
mail@paystream.co.uk
Umbrella.co.ukVariable: circa gross £20YES (both options: accrued and not accrued)YESWorkplace pension scheme via NEST
Company scheme via Carey
Not supported0800 121 6513
0162 5546 610
https://www.umbrella.co.uk/umbrella-services/what-umbrella-companycostumer.services@umbrella.co.uk

3. Additional or value-add services of ‘Umbrella Company’ in the IR35 regime operations

As part of any commercial negotiations I always look for additional services included in the price, free or reasonably priced value-add features or simply freebies.

3.1 Claiming of business expenses

For a start, to make life difficult for the freelance community, who are ‘bathing in privileges and free-lunches’, HMRC imposes a special regime for deciding on the eligibility for claiming business expenses – enter the Supervision, Direction or Control (SDC) assessment (I refer here to HMRC’s ‘Guidance for Employment intermediaries: personal services and supervision, direction or control’, 6 April 2016; expected to be revised by April 2020). There are two outcomes of a compulsory SDC assessment, which can be influenced by your immediate client by stipulating the regime in the contract role and carried out either by the Agent and/or the Umbrella Company:

  • Most common outcome for the status within the SDC is the following setup: “Umbrella no expenses – for lower-paid workers, or those who are under SDC (or the right of)”;
  • If the status is outside SDC then some Umbrella Company Service Providers may support a varying range of expenses associated with self-employed services, such as (not a definitive list, illustration only):
    • Business mileage;
    • Travel;
    • Subsistence;
    • Temporary accommodation;
    • Tools and equipment;
    • Software;
    • Capital expenditure;
    • Professional subscriptions;
    • Cost of DBS/background checks;
    • Eye tests;
    • Safety wear;
    • Training, exams + associated travel/meals;
    • Consumables (postage, stationary);
    • Business calls.

Here comes Lesson Number 4:

  1. Claiming of business expenses is a statutory right of any self-employed freelancer. Make sure your role is correctly defined and treated with regard to the SDC rule, i.e. the role is very similar to permanent employment, where all business aspects are either covered by the client or simply not factored in due to the nature of the role.
  2. Choose an Umbrella Company Service Provider, who have an open mind, i.e. ready to run their own independent SDC eligibility assessment free of charge for you and confirm their readiness to run the expense claims within their payroll services for you.
  3. Unless you always work in roles under SDC, steer clear of those Umbrella Company Service Providers, which have a blanket policy of ‘Umbrella no expenses’ or those not having an accounting support capability to run such a service.

As a professional with micro- and macro-economic background I find the SDC rule as restrictive towards the overall mobility of the UK freelance workforce. Some UK areas will be left unserviceable due to the combination of low contract rates under inside IR35, nature of the roles (e.g. specific expertise) and their remote location (expensive travel and accommodation rates). Body-shops and consultancies are rubbing their hands in expectation of a free-lunch with regard to filling in the demand, but would they employ UK taxpayers to do such jobs? This remains an open issue associated with the consequences of IR35.

The above means that the UK’s Minister of State for Employment, who are supposed to stay on guard for monopolistic tendencies and maintain a level playing field in terms of fair competition for jobs, are failing the UK taxpayers. Filling the pockets of private consulting companies (a significant number of which are foreign HQed and are not under the UK jurisdiction for the purposes of tax for their working visa employees) cannot be considered as ‘making Britain wealthy and prosperous’. Phew, I probably said something considered a taboo topic …..

3.2 Additional payroll administration services

When compiling answers into Table 1 I’ve enquired if various additional payroll administration services are included or supported, such as:

  1. Various Certificates of Income or Employment for mortgage applications, proof of income, etc.). Do they come at cost or are they get included in the Company Net Margin. Lesson Number 5: ask for the confirmation and/or price list in writing;
  2. For those still under the education related debt Lesson Number 6: confirm that the Umbrella Company have the capability and are willing to run your Student Loan Deductions in the payroll as a standard service, i.e. free of charge;
  3. It is important to save and one of the best ways to do this and get a top up from the government is to organise contributions into your own private pension fund via the Umbrella Company’s payroll service. Lesson Number 7: ask whether the service is supported free of charge. As you can see from Table 1, not many Umbrella Company Service Providers will provide this service, which means that you will have to do this yourself from the net pay and then settle the difference with HMRC through the annual Self-Assessment, i.e. additional admin for you;
  4. Some of the Umbrella Company Service Providers are also nationally renowned Accountancy Service Providers, this may come handy with discounts for personal finance or additional business (e.g. Limited Company) service support.

3.3 Other additional services and Service Level Agreements (SLAs)

Among other additional benefits feature the following perks:

  • I specifically asked all respondents whether they offer enrolment into a private health care plan or insurance. Arguably, as a large employer Umbrella Company Service Providers will possess a significant bargaining power to negotiate a great Corporate Health Plan with one of the major providers. Alas, none of the surveyed Service Providers offer a Medical Plan.
  • Various high street retail discounts;
  • Availability of a Contractor Portal features as a perk, but is available across the board from all surveyed Service Providers.

Service SLAs are a difficult category to assess objectively, but I’ll try:

  • I found only one written on a website reference to an SLA: “Respond to all queries within 24 hours and have a complaints procedure”. For me it is a real commitment;
  • As a rule of thumb, I’ve looked under the tab ‘Contact us’ and availability of chat on the Umbrella Company Service Providers’ websites:
  • Diversified structure of services with separate phone numbers and emails theoretically indicates that there are multiple dedicated teams and their performance to deal with your enquiries or needs may be better …., but there’s no guarantee in this world;
  • Again, for fans of bot-chats and other digital ways of communication, availability of a chat service may be a welcome feature of advanced customer service. I did not test them in my exercise for effectiveness or responsiveness.
  • Lesson Number 8: ask specifically for the commitment on Customer Service, if you need a certificate or an urgent resolution on tax matters, you do not want it to last for weeks.

Disclaimer: please note that due to on-going reviews of IR35 by the Government and HMRC all information provided in Table 1, under the links and even on Service Providers websites is subject to change. Always check the latest updates and seek professional advice before you take any contractual, financial and business action or enter into a transaction.

Consider calling a number of Service Providers, ask for all available options, ask for detailed calculations and T&Cs sent to you in writing, ask your colleagues for references and testimonials (word of mouth) on reputation of Service Providers.

Information on Service Providers in Table 1 is not provided as recommendation, rather as demonstration of capabilities and contact details. The full list of qualifying Service Providers is provided on FCSA website at https://www.fcsa.org.uk/members/

Leave a Reply