The history of children / teenage influencers does not start in the 20th century. It does not even start with Joan of Arc in 15th century. It goes back to the times when songs, stories, myths and fables were people’s books, television, internet and social media.
The paper analyses the origin and activities of a number of prominent child and teenage activists through a lens of a phenomenon known as ‘Framing Effect’ in the Psychology of Behaviour of Individuals and Groups. For as long we had the practice of influencing people, naturally or with intent, Framing Effect has been employed to shape people’s beliefs and modify their motivations.
Children-influencers in mythology, religion and folklore
A Spartan boy, who does not whimper, whilst a stolen fox-cub eats his (the boy’s) intestines to avoid implicating himself and his friend in a theft. You see, back then, the deeds were contained to protect honour and, sometimes, freedom, of a single nation or group of people. Pagan heroes and iconic figures knew nothing and cared little about the big good world that might have needed their patronage.
Multinational folklores around the world have a child-hero or a child-freedom fighter in their epos. Naming them can fill a multi-volume encyclopaedia. Child-heroes, who really fascinated me, were the ones possessing prominent leadership characteristics.
You think I will start with the most celebrated child of them all? Well no, the first child-hero to grip my imagination was Väinämöinen from Karelian-Finish epos Kalevala. Born as a demigod, he raises to the rank of the leader of the “sons of Kaleva” (the land of heroes), fights evil whenever he comes across it, but still essentially remains very human in his thoughts, behaviour and deeds. He is a powerful seer and artistically plays the kantele, a Finnish stringed instrument that resembles a zither.
You’d assume that his path is always branded with laurels and he boasts 150% popularity rating and constantly smashes billboards as a “Man of the Year”. Nope. One of his brides-to-be, Joukahainen’s sister Aino, drowns herself, rather than face a prospect of marrying him.
However, a hero is always a hero, despite a no-confidence vote from the local brides, Väinämöinen and his group of merry men (all heroes, of course) steal the Sampo, a public domain artefact of the people of Pohjola (predictably, the land of ‘dark and evil’). Väinämöinen’s end has always gripped me, because it is said that his spirit and genetic code lives in every still-nature, beast and human being of the North.
And, not to disappoint, there is the baby, then a boy, then a teenager and, finally, the Man – Jesus of Nazareth. There is no need to narrate the deeds of this prodigious youngster, just punch the name into a search-engine – overwhelming information for all types of curious or casual reader.
Girls vs Boys: the art of influencing

As with the previous two characters, inspirational origins and enigmatic inspiration are indisputable. What matters is the magnitude of inspiration and so-called global reach. Also, notably, with a few exceptions in Greco-Roman mythology in general and specifically myths about the Amazons, majority of the teenage heroes are boys. Mark this point, as I will come back to it later in the discussion.
I’ve been constantly tempted to mention Wonder Woman, an ultimate Amazon, who lived and made her mark in the current urban culture, but resisted the temptation. My objective is to depict a cumulative image of a child/ teenage-hero that modern people can relate to. The narrative and philosophical point has to be connected to reality as closely as possible. Talk of gods and demigods leads us into supernatural and somewhat mystical spheres. Let’s keep reality as our domain.
Maid of Orleans: girl-influencer recognised by the Church!
At a certain point, society matured to the level of moving away from the long list of male dominated teenage-heroes – enter first female movers and shakers. Joan of Arc, without doubt, stands out as the most prominent teenage-girl, who challenged the establishment and medieval status quo.


By no means do I want to diminish the cultural and societal influence of other young female figures before or after Joan. But, the majority of them made their appearance and mark as a ‘daughter of so and so’ or a ‘wife of so and so’. Young Joan is always going to be the Maid of Orleans, i.e. no direct connection to a male ‘protector or sponsor’. Although, it is said that she heard the voice and order from God to fight the oppressors. But there is a current debate that God may actually be a woman, so we will let this insignificant detail pass.
But the real proliferation of teenage-girls as modern world ambassadors of peace and progress started in the second half of the 20th century, when the world had been threatened with total nuclear annihilation.
20th century ‘Goodwill Ambassador’: Samantha Smith


In 1982 at the age of 10, an American child actress, Samantha Reed Smith, visited the Soviet Union on the invitation from the CPSU General Secretary Yuri Andropov. She did not meet Andropov in person, but spent time at the elite international pioneer camp Artek in Crimea. Due to the massive resonance of Samatha’s mission at the USSR, she was named a “Goodwill Ambassador”, became known as “America’s Youngest Ambassador”, wrote her narrative in a book Journey to the Soviet Union and carried out a peace mission in Japan. Her life tragically ended at the age of 13 in a plane crash in August 1985, which she boarded with her father, a co-author of her famous book.
Key to the mind of ‘Iron Felix’: Yuri Andropov
This chapter in the history of peace-making during the Cold War era was rich with surreal events, coincidences and parallels:

- Yuri Andropov, who so generously extended the historic invitation to Samantha, was an orthodox KGB General. His whole professional life was to defend and protect Soviet values and way of life. Suddenly, a Confucian act of wisdom and enlightenment – reach out to the West via a child ambassador, really?
- They said, that post the notorious Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962 during the Nikita Khrushchev’s reign, Yuri Andropov was the most feared ‘paranoid’ enemy of the West. Was he really?
- Andropov served only two years as the CPSU General Secretary between 1982 and 1984, before his death from kidney failure in February 1984;
- Yuri Andropov had been the boss (maybe not directly) to a young KGB officer – Vladimir Putin.
This is how the past connects to the present ….
Copy-cat ‘Goodwill Ambassador’: Katya Lycheva

My narrative continues with another “Goodwill Ambassador”, Katya Lycheva, this time a Soviet child actress. In 1986 11-year old Katya, accompanied by Star Rowe, an American 11-year old girl, visited major US cities and met President Ronald Reagan. This visit to the US was popularised in a book Making Friends: Katya from Moscow and Star from San Francisco : Two Eleven-Year-Old Girls Discover America Together in 1987.
Apart from the above book, the media and the Internet have little or no evidence of a lasting friendship between Katya and her new American friends: Ronald and Star. The role of Star, apart from a pretentious name for publicity (e.g. American flag has STARs and stripes), in Katya’s visit to the US is not entirely clear. For anyone who cares, the name Katerina has symbolic connotation in the post-Soviet countries: starting from Catherine the Great and finishing with a pet-name Katyusha, a famous truck-mounted land-to-land rocket launcher, which is still one of the iconic symbols for the Soviet victory in WWII.
Key to the minds of ‘Iron Lady’ and ‘Teflon President’: Ronald Reagan
President Reagan’s initiative to warrant Katya’s visit and meet her personally can have a number of motivations:

- Samantha’s mission did not have any notable effect on the US-Soviet military doctrines, international cooperation or containing on-going regional military conflicts that involved both sides directly or indirectly. Reagan, always a populist, could not resist a temptation to appear in the limelight as a promoter of another peacemaking mission;
- Samantha’s mission was criticised in the US as an attempt at Soviet propaganda. Opinions and perceptions are often polarised. So, endorsing Katya’s visit to the US was Reagan’s propaganda attempt aimed at the Soviet people;
- In the author’s opinion, most likely the motivation was to start building a ‘bridge’ with Mikhail Gorbachev, a new CPSU General Secretary.
In 1988, Katya emigrated with her mother to Paris, France, only to return to new capitalist Russia in 2000. Since then, allegedly, Yekaterina Alexandrovna Lycheva lives a reclusive life, away from the limelight and, God forbid, politics. Even unscrupulous Russian correspondents have found it difficult to trace Katya and her daughter in an attempt to obtain an interview.
‘The Marked Man’s’ agenda: Mikhail Gorbachev

By this point of the narrative, a curious reader impatiently shifts weight and asks: “What is the connection between 11-year old movie stars of Soviet and US heritage, their peacemaking activities and the Big World we live in today?” I am giving you a connection – no more Soviet Union or a Soviet Camp. And it all started, and in a way, ended with this man – Mikhail Gorbachev. From 1985 to 1991 he was the CPSU General Secretary and from 15 March 1990 to 25 December 1991 – the first President of the Soviet Union.
‘Father of Soviet People’ was also ‘Children’s Friend’: Josef Stalin

Fifty years ahead of Reagan and Gorbachev another leader had a good grasp on manipulating public sentiment: Josef Stalin. Yes, you guessed correctly, iconic images and even statues of him with representatives of the younger generation. In 1936 The photo of Stalin and Gelya, a.k.a. ‘Children’s friend’ was published around the world; in the Internet age we would say: ‘It went viral’.

‘Friendship’ with the Father of the Soviet People did not save Engelsina (Gelya) Markizova’s parents: her father was executed as a Japanese spy in 1938 and her mother was allegedly assassinated in the same year. Gelya mercifully survived (died in 2004 at the age of 75) Stalin’s repressions (purges), lived as an ordinary Soviet citizen, working as an Orientalist.
In state propaganda, Stalin could not be associated with a daughter of an enemy of the state. Remember, photos in all periodicals and the statues all over the country! So, Gelya’s name was replaced with the name of Mamlakat Nakhangova, a famous Young Pioneer. But, we heard Gelya’s story at last.
Framing Effect: political and social behaviour in the East and West
It would be naive to assume that a couple of peacemaking missions by 11-year old girls persuaded hard-core Soviet and US top brass to change their ideological convictions and embrace each other in paroxysm of brotherly love.
The image-makers and propaganda specialists went for the game and behavioural psychology method known as ‘framing effect’ where frames influence beliefs, and beliefs influence motivations. A message of peace and unity could have been delivered by any diplomat from either of the sides, and probably, better and more coherently. However, 11-year old girls were chosen as the messengers, the effect of the message had been ‘framed’.
I think, the effect was important to the image of the top leaders in the first place: Reagan and Gorbachev. Now certain summits and discussions were conducted, and more importantly, perceived by rank-and-file party members and the general public as goodwill events. No longer a standoff of two belligerent sides, but a dialogue of two concerned parties, who take care of their people and ….. children.
Not for a second do I doubt the sincerity and integrity of either Samantha or Katya, when they accepted their missions. What a 11-year old girl may know about ‘framed messages’ that influence beliefs, and beliefs influence motivations and contributions? What I find remarkable is how these goodwill ambassadors, after the mission was accomplished, faded away from the cultural and social horizon.
Frames influenced beliefs

For a start, both missions rapidly came under massive criticism within both camps as an attempt at propaganda of the style of life and beliefs: classic East vs West. Similarity in the methods used for the initial contact (a letter to the country’s leader), programme of the visit and grand finale in the form of a book, point towards a well-rehearsed professional mechanism of public opinion manipulation. And the public needed constant reminders of the spirit of friendship; tensions in both countries had been growing – the Soviet Union was being dismantled from the outside and the inside. Not child’s play any more, serious business!
‘The Greta Effect’: Greta Thunberg

For our group of teenage-influencers, Greta Tintin Eleonora Ernman Thunberg entered the world stage a bit late – she was 15-years old during her ‘School Strike for Climate’ in front of the Swedish Parliament in August 2018.
Remarkably, as in the case of Anne Frank, Greta had been raised with high sense of social responsibility and sharp critical reasoning. Greta turns her diagnosed Asperger’s syndrome, OCD and selective mutism into a strength: “That basically means I only speak when I think it’s necessary”.
Even when she is not presenting at the world’s economic and climate summits or leading thousands of teenagers at climate rallies, Greta is omni-present with her punchy speeches, tweets and quotes: “People are suffering. People are dying. Entire ecosystems are collapsing. We are in the beginning of a mass extinction. And all you can talk about is money and fairy tales of eternal economic growth. How dare you!”, “Our house is still on fire.” and “I am being heard all the time.”
Again, as in the case with the publication of Anne Frank’s diary, Greta’s climate protection activities and speeches were not noticed immediately. Hence, I make a conclusion that the framing effect was deployed later, when the media and climate change organisations realised the strength of Greta’s character and magnetism. The first attempt to profiteer from the framing effect or ‘Greta Effect’ was by Swedish climate-focused social media company We Don’t Have Time (WDHT), founded and led by Ingmar Rentzhog. By chance or good guidance (her father?) Greta avoided financial association with the company and distanced herself in time to save her climate movement’s integrity.
‘The Most Famous Teenager in the World’: Malala Yousafzai
The title was coined by Deutsche Welle in January 2013 (her Regional and International Rewards and Honours take a whole page on Wikipedia) following Malala’s dramatic recovery from being shot in the head by a Taliban assassin in October 2012. At the time of the attack Malala Yousafzai was a 13-year old activist-blogger against the Taliban occupation of Swat (her district of Pakistan) and already a nominee for the International Children’s Peace Prize. Her story went viral, caused massive regional and international resonance and Malala’s path as a female educational activist was launched.

For our narrative, the following coincidence is important. At the age of 11, Malala had been following in the footsteps of her father, Ziauddin Yousafzai, a Pakistani activist for the freedom of education. In 2009 Malala wrote a blog for BBC Urdu about the Taliban occupation of her region and in 2010, New York Times featured her in a documentary as the region was liberated by the Pakistani military.
Yet another successful ‘framing’ of the media stories through the blog written by an 11-year old girl. Remember, frames influence beliefs. Price of ‘framing’ – a near-miss assassination attempt on Malala’s life and potential mortal danger for her entire family and friends.
Beliefs influenced motivations
What is remarkable in Malala’s story is that this time the Pakistani and the world’s public not only took notice and reacted with reforms for women’s rights and education; they kept promoting the ‘ambassador’ to new activist career highs and international prominence.
Out of all teenage-influencers in our story, Malala is the closest to Joan of Ark: a display of personal courage and sacrifice in the face of real danger (Swat was a war zone at the time of writing of her first diary) and persistence in her goals (she did not stop self-development and activism).
Types of Influencers and Timing of the Framing Effect
Born or made an influencer
One of the observations I’ve made in the cause of the research is that there are two distinct groups of teenage-influencers: ‘natural’ and ‘manufactured’.
‘Natural’ influencers
Joan of Arc, Anne Frank, Greta Thunberg and Malala Yousafzai represent the ‘Natural’ teenage-influencers group. Characteristics of teenagers in this group are:
- Natural intelligence and emotional maturity, beyond the average for the age group;
- Possess high sense of social responsibility;
- Naturally artistic, determined and imaginative;
- Direct communication style, outside of the boundaries prescribed by the popular opinion to the age group and social status;
- Family legacy. Well, maybe not in the case of Joan. Anne’s father was a liberal Jewish businessman. Malala’s father is a freedom and education activist. Greta’s mother is an opera singer and father – an actor (grandfather – an actor and producer);
- For the purity of comparison, I make an observation that Anne Frank’s diary was written without an explicit intent to influence. However, there is no doubt about Anne’s unique personality and ability to write an inspirational narrative of horrible events of the Holocaust.
- Unlimited time of activism of the ‘natural’ influencer as a consequence of free-will.
‘Manufactured’ influencers
The second influencers’ group I named ‘Manufactured’, because ‘framing’ had been pre-meditated and the persona of the influencer was carefully ‘casted’ and coached. Without any prejudice to the individuals, their media personas had been professionally designed, manufactured and maintained to serve the purpose of a political leader or political group. In my narrative they are: Engelsina Markizova, Samantha Smith and Katya Lycheva. Characteristics of ‘manufactured personas’ in this group are:
- Typical representatives of their age group, in this case, type of a good ‘pre-teenage girl next door’;
- Naturally artistic, photogenic and charismatic;
- Neutral, ideologically or politically correct (depending on the ideology) communication style;
- Absence of free-will in choosing influencing activities;
- Family should remain firmly in the background: exist, but not overshadow the ‘manufactured’ influencer’s activities;
- Limited timeframe of the ‘manufactured’ influencer operation.
Timing of ‘framing’
I also observe the timing of the ‘framing’, there are two distinct modes directly correlated to the type of influencer:
- Timed before the influencer’s activism: inherent to the ‘manufactured’ influencer type is fully or partially pre-meditated ‘framing’ that impacts beliefs and motivations. A ‘manufactured’ influencer may be under the effect of the ‘framing’, i.e. promote beliefs and motivations pre-meditated by a third-party ;
- Timed during or after the establishment of the influencer and their activity: free-will activism of the ‘natural’ influencer is noticed and gets subjected to ‘framing’. This type of ‘framing’ may be exercised both with or without the influencer’s consent. Therefore, the ‘natural’ influencer always has a choice either to distance herself from certain groups/individuals/causes or join forces with them.
The actions of Engelsina Markizova, Samantha Smith and Katya Lycheva are without doubt examples of fully pre-meditated ‘framing’, timed before their personas gained popular recognition and phased out when the objectives of the third-party were achieved.
Anne Frank’s diary publication is a prime example of post-event ‘framing’ without the influencer’s consent. It took multiple attempts to raise public awareness of the ‘child’s voice’, before the diary was published in the Netherlands in 1947, followed by publication in Germany and France in 1950 and in the UK and the US in 1952.
‘Greta’s Effect’ is entirely an authentic product of Greta’s free-will and activism. ‘Framing’ of Greta’s messages to impact public beliefs and motivations by third-parties started after the demonstration at the Swedish Parliament, climate rallies, publications and public speeches.
The activism of Malala started with a fully pre-meditated ‘framed’ blog by BBC Urdu and New York Times documentary feature. After the recapture of Swat by Pakistani military, the activist path of Malala might have stalled or continued on the regional level, similar to Samantha and Katya’s peacemaking activities. However, the assassination attempt has propelled Malala to the international level of recognition and status of an independent influencer. The sky is the limit now for Malala! (using B. Obama’s favourite phrase).
Correlation between the type, timing of ‘framing’ and the legacy of the influencer
There is a direct correlation between the speed of absorption of the framing effect, effectiveness of means of communication and technical advance in media channels.
De-centralisation of state control, their relative independence and global reach of social media channels in established democracies and their satellites are to the advantage of ‘natural’ influencers. However, the same characteristics of the media channels aid the proliferation of the framing effect by third-parties without consent of the original influencer. Negative effects range from ‘trolling’ to misinterpretation of the original messages and activities.
I specifically point out an observation that super-powers such as the USA, Russia and China typically produce ‘manufactured’ influencers, especially in the pre- and teenage groups. Inherent to super-powers is a patriarchal style of governing and framing of public beliefs and motivations. Mere independence of Greta’s activism goes against the politico-social doctrines of super-powers: influencers, especially teenagers, have to be manufactured and ‘framing’ has to be pre-meditated.
Last but not least, I observe that ‘natural’ teenage-influencers continue their activism as young adults due to free-will and independence from the framing effects instigated by third-parties. Another important observation is that non-‘manufactured’ influencers receive their international honours and nominations in person. For example, it was Mikhail Gorbachev who received the Ronald Reagan Freedom Award and the Peace Nobel Prize, not Samantha or Katya. The world of today honours ‘natural’ influencers, such as Malala and Greta, for their own achievements. They are not ‘framed’ proxies for third-parties.
Disclosure: Financial Botanik is not supported by referral fees from any party. The article does not cover each and every participant in the market or all of their product / services. The information which is contained in these articles is subject to change at any time. Financial Botanik aims to help readers gain better understanding of the market and its driving events, promote discussion and increase financial awareness.
